Would the Anti Defamation League have opposed Park 51, the controversial Islamic cultural center and Mosque, had its founder, Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, sought to develop the center in a building that was twelve as opposed to just two blocks away from Ground Zero?
Distance from the Epicenter
Questions about distance and radius are not unfamiliar to anyone who living in NY during and after the 9/11/01 terrorist attacks. The Red Cross and FEMA had their red zone maps. Trauma, a topic also discussed in my July 4th Fireworks Politiku, is very real to those who suffer in its aftermath. What 9/11 victims experienced, suffered from and in some cases are still suffering from, deserves all the support and respect one would expect from a socially conscious and sensitized civilization.
What I just don’t get about all this
Will having a Mosque and cultural center near ground Zero, truly deepen the suffering of a 9/11 survivor simply because it is there to serve a community of moderate Islamic practitioners?
Given the complex nature of trauma and how it manifests, I honestly don’t see how a 9/11 survivor’s response to Park 51 would be any easier to predict than other potential emotional triggers in that part of town.
As someone who was downtown the morning of the attacks, I go to that part of the city when I have to and co-exist with the discomfort as best I can. It’s constantly changing as are the different things that get to me about being there. Would an Islamic cultural center resonate with me as anything besides an Islamic cultural center? Probably not.
The Perceived Threat
I grew up in an educated, politically involved, middle-class Jewish family in Washington, D.C. and have chosen to reside in multicultural cities for most of my adult life because it is where I feel most at ease. I am not afraid of a moderate Islamic cultural center with an interfaith focus because, for me, ignorance, intolerance and extremism is the greater threat.
I do not agree with all of Imam Feisal Abdul Raufmight’s politics –but then– I disagree with a lot of my friend’s politics, as well.
Isn’t this what living and thriving in a multicultural urban metropolis is all about?
The Actual Threat
The actual threat, as I see it, is a potential anti-semitic backlash that the ADL’s intolerance could unintentionally end up causing.
Hopefully those following the issue will understand that the ADL’s extremist position does not represent all Jews. Hopefully…
Politiku Submission Call
Please email Politiku submissions on this topic along with your first and last name and url (if you’d like us to link to it) to Guest Assistant Editor, Rachel Levy by 9:00 p.m. EST on Tuesday, August 2nd.
Rachel’s email address is levy166 (at) gmail.com We hope the Politiku will represent a wide range of Jewish voices on this issue and will post the Politiku we select on Huffpo.
Need the run down or a refresher on what, exactly, Politiku is? Visit the FAQ section of our Facebook Fan page and follow our tweets as well!












Pete Orvetti’s* Inauguration Day Politikus
I swear solemnly
Word order doesn’t mean much
When you are The One
Hope, change, Yes We Can
Port-A-Potties everywhere
Change-Fest on the Mall
Nope, we didn’t go
Someday my sons will be mad
Crowds and change scare me
Yo Yo Oba-Ma
And the Queen of Soul
Wish I had her hat